Comparisons of Four Methods for Thinning Eucalyptus Hybrid Coppice Shoots in Brazil

Main Article Content

Nilton Cesar Fiedler
Ricardo Pinheiro Cabral
Adriano Ribeiro de Mendonça
Weslen Pintor Canzian
Antonio Henrique Cordeiro Ramalho
Denise Ransolin Soranso


Both manual and semi-mechanized systems are used for operations involved in coppice remodeling. Thus, there is a paradigm about the higher yield of semi-mechanized operations compared to manual operations. However, the small volume of research on this subject does not present data which is capable of confirming this hypothesis. Thus, the present study aimed to perform a technical analysis of costs, quality and productivity of different methods for conducting regrowth in Eucalyptus grandis x Eucalyptus urophylla hybrid plantations under coppice regeneration in areas of forest fostering. The experiment was conducted under a completely randomized design with four treatments (sprouting methods) and four replications in plots of 360m² each. The methods used were: brushcutter, sickle, machete and hand digger. An F-test (p <0.05) was performed to verify the differentiation between treatments for a given characteristic after verifying the normal distribution of data and homogeneity of variances. The means were compared by analysis of variance at the 5% significance level to analyze if there was significant difference between the operating times in the analyzed methods. An estimate of the costs per hectare was subsequently obtained in each offspring method and the quality of the operation was evaluated by observing the frequency of damage to the remaining trunk. The mean operation time of the methods did not differ significantly (p> 0.05). The brushcutter presented the highest cost per hectare (US$ 40,06/ha-1) and the excavator presented the lowest (US$ 18,65/ha-1). Spreading with the brushcutter presented the lowest percentage of mechanical damage (6.88%) and the sickle obtained the highest (20.63%). It was concluded that the operation with brushcutter was the method that provided the highest productivity, but has the highest operational cost, making the method with brushcutter, advantageous for its low cost, associated with a satisfactory productivity.

Coppice, forestry techniques and operations, operating profit, regrowth driving.

Article Details

How to Cite
Cesar Fiedler, N., Pinheiro Cabral, R., Ribeiro de Mendonça, A., Pintor Canzian, W., Henrique Cordeiro Ramalho, A., & Ransolin Soranso, D. (2019). Comparisons of Four Methods for Thinning Eucalyptus Hybrid Coppice Shoots in Brazil. Journal of Experimental Agriculture International, 41(6), 1-7.
Short Research Article


Lopes ES, Tonhato L, Rodrigues CK, Serpe EL. Terrain slope and extraction distance on forwarder productivity with auxiliary drive winch. Native, Sinop. 2016; 4(6):347-352.

Queiroz AM, Silva ZAGPG. Economic aspects of eucalyptus (Eucalyptus spp.) plantations in the Lower Acre region. Forest, Curitiba. 2016;46(3):287-296.

Schettino S, Minette LJ, Soranso DR, Camarinha ACM, Schettino CF. Ergonomic assessment of forest harvesting in wind-damaged woodland. ACSA, Ducks. 2018; 14(1):70-78.

Ibá - Brazilian Tree Industry. 2019 Report. São Paulo; 2019.

Bellé C, Groth MZ, Kaspary TE, Khun PR, Kulczynski SM. Reproduction of Pratylenchus spp. in eucalyptus species (Eucalyptus spp.). Nematropica. 2018; 48(1):45-49.

Righi CA, Couderc V, Pereira CR, Couto HTZ. Responses of Eucalyptus camaldulensis sprouts to shade: An evaluation of canopy plasticity. Expl. Agric. 2016;52(3):346-358.

Lima ASF, Gonçalves JLM, Gonçalves AN. Effect of nutrient omission on eucalyptus shoots. Nucleus. 2018;15(1):147-160.

Gadelha FHL, Silva JAA, Ferreira RLC, Santos RC, Tavares JA. Productivity of eucalyptus clones in different management systems for energy purposes. Search flower. Bras. Colombo. 2015;35(83):263-270.

Gonçalves JC, Oliveira AD, Carvalho SPC, Gomide LR. Economic analysis of forest rotation of eucalyptus stands using Monte Carlo simulation. Forest Science, Santa Maria. 2017;27(4):1339-1347.

Leite ES, Fernandes HC, Guedes IL, Amaral EJ. Technical and cost analysis of semi-mechanized logging in eucalyptus stands in different spacings. Cerne. 2014; 20(3):637-643.

Cunha JPB, Silva FM, Andrade F, Machado TA, Batista FA. Technical and economic analysis of different coffee transplantation systems (Coffea arabica L.). Coffee Science, Lavras. 2015;10(3): 289-297.